Rakuten vs TopCashback vs Honey: Which Cashback App Is Best?

If you've ever Googled "best cashback app," you've probably seen Rakuten, TopCashback, and Honey recommended. But they're actually quite different products, and the smartest shoppers don't just pick one — they use two of them strategically.

We compared all three platforms across rates, payout methods, store coverage, and real-world usability. Here's what we found.

The Quick Verdict

How Each Platform Works

Rakuten

Rakuten (formerly Ebates) is the biggest cashback portal in the U.S. with 17+ million members and $4.6 billion paid out since 1999. The concept is simple: click through Rakuten to a store, shop normally, and Rakuten gives you a percentage of your purchase back as cash.

Rakuten makes money because retailers pay them a commission for sending shoppers their way. Rakuten keeps a portion of that commission and shares the rest with you as cashback.

Best for: Beginners, people who want the most reliable and well-known platform, and anyone who shops at Amazon (Rakuten often has exclusive Amazon cashback offers).

TopCashback

TopCashback is the underdog that frequently beats Rakuten on rates. They claim to pass 100% of the retailer commission to members, making their money from advertising and premium features instead. In practice, this often means their cashback percentages are 1-5% higher than Rakuten at the same store.

Best for: Savvy shoppers willing to compare rates, people making large purchases where even 1-2% difference matters, and anyone who wants the absolute highest cashback possible.

Honey (by PayPal)

Honey is fundamentally different from Rakuten and TopCashback. It's primarily a coupon code finder — a browser extension that automatically tests promo codes at checkout. It also has a rewards program called Honey Gold, where you earn points redeemable for gift cards, but the earning rates are significantly lower than dedicated cashback portals.

Best for: Finding coupon codes automatically. NOT best for cashback — use it alongside Rakuten or TopCashback, not instead of them.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Rakuten	TopCashback	Honey
Primary Function	Cashback portal	Cashback portal	Coupon finder + minor rewards
Signup Bonus	$50	$10	500 Gold (≈$5)
# of Stores	3,500+	7,000+	30,000+ (coupons)
Cashback Rates	1-18%	1-20% (often higher)	1-5% Honey Gold (lower)
Payout Method	PayPal or check	Bank, PayPal, or gift cards	Gift cards only
Payout Schedule	Quarterly (every 3 months)	After purchase confirms (varies)	When you redeem Gold
Browser Extension	Yes — excellent, auto-activates	Yes — good, rate alerts	Yes — excellent for coupons
Mobile App	Yes	Yes	Yes (limited)
In-Store Cashback	Yes (link card)	Limited	No
Referral Bonus	$50 per referral	$40 per referral	500 Gold per referral
Reliability	Excellent — very consistent tracking	Good — occasional tracking hiccups	N/A for cashback

Real Cashback Rate Comparison

We checked rates at 12 popular stores across all three platforms. Here's what we found (rates as of March 2026 — these change frequently):

Store	Rakuten	TopCashback	Honey Gold	Winner
Nike	8%	9.5%	~1%	TopCashback
Target	11% (boosted)	4%	1%	Rakuten
Macy's	18%	15%	~2%	Rakuten
Sephora	6%	6%	1%	Tie
Best Buy	3%	4%	1%	TopCashback
Walmart	4%	5%	1%	TopCashback
eBay	4%	4%	1%	Tie
Amazon	$5 flat	Varies	~1%	Depends on order size
Ulta Beauty	6%	7%	1%	TopCashback
Expedia	5%	8%	N/A	TopCashback
Old Navy/Gap	8%	6%	~2%	Rakuten
CVS	15%	10%	N/A	Rakuten

Score: TopCashback wins at 5 stores, Rakuten wins at 4, 2 ties, 1 depends. This is why using both is the move — neither one consistently beats the other across all stores.

The Browser Extension Experience

Rakuten Extension

When you visit a partnered store, a small popup appears showing the cashback rate and an "Activate" button. One click and your shopping trip is tracked. It also alerts you if there are any active coupon codes. Clean, unobtrusive, reliable. This is the best cashback extension, period.

TopCashback Extension

Similar concept — alerts you when cashback is available and lets you activate with one click. Also shows you the rate and sometimes compares it to competitors. Slightly less polished than Rakuten's but fully functional.

Honey Extension

At checkout, Honey automatically tries every available coupon code and applies the best one. This is genuinely useful and saves time. However, Honey's own rewards (Honey Gold) are much lower than Rakuten or TopCashback rates. Use Honey for coupons, not for cashback.

Payout Comparison

Rakuten Payouts

Rakuten pays quarterly — they call it "Big Fat Check" day. Your cashback accumulates, then on February 15, May 15, August 15, and November 15, Rakuten sends your balance via PayPal or physical check. Minimum payout is $5.

Pros: PayPal is instant and convenient. Cons: Quarterly payouts mean you wait up to 3 months.

TopCashback Payouts

TopCashback pays once each individual purchase's cashback is confirmed by the retailer (usually 30-90 days after purchase). You can cash out to your bank, PayPal, or gift cards. Gift cards often come with a bonus — for example, a $25 Amazon gift card might only cost $23.75 in cashback.

Pros: More frequent payouts, gift card bonuses. Cons: Confirmation times vary and can be slow.

Honey Payouts

Honey Gold is redeemable for gift cards only (no cash or PayPal). You need 1,000 Gold to redeem a $10 gift card. Earning rates are low — typically 100-500 Gold per purchase.

Verdict: Honey's rewards are a minor bonus for using their coupon tool. Don't count on them as a cashback strategy.

Our Recommended Setup

Based on our testing, here's the optimal configuration:

1. Sign up for Rakuten ($50 bonus) — your primary cashback portal and extension
2. Sign up for TopCashback — your secondary portal for rate comparison
3. Install Honey — for automatic coupon code finding at checkout
4. Before each purchase over $30: Quick-check both Rakuten and TopCashback rates (15 seconds). Use whichever is higher.
5. At checkout: Let Honey try coupon codes automatically

This setup takes about 60 seconds per purchase and maximizes your savings across all three layers: highest cashback rate + automatic coupon codes + credit card rewards.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Rakuten and TopCashback on the same purchase?

No. You can only go through one cashback portal per purchase. The portal you click through last is the one that will track the cashback. Pick whichever has the higher rate for that specific store.

Does using a cashback portal affect the price I pay?

No. You pay the exact same price as if you went to the store directly. The cashback comes out of the commission the retailer pays the portal — it costs you nothing extra.

Can I use Honey coupons alongside Rakuten cashback?

Yes! Honey's coupon-finding feature works at the checkout level and doesn't interfere with Rakuten's cashback tracking. You get the portal cashback AND the coupon discount. This is the whole point of triple-dipping.

What if my cashback doesn't track?

Both Rakuten and TopCashback have "missing cashback" claim processes. If a purchase doesn't track within a few days, you can file a claim with your order confirmation number. In our experience, Rakuten resolves these more quickly and consistently than TopCashback.

Are these platforms safe? Will they sell my data?

Rakuten is owned by the Japanese e-commerce giant Rakuten Group and has been operating since 1999. TopCashback has been around since 2005. Honey is owned by PayPal. All three are legitimate, well-established companies. They do collect shopping data (that's how they work), but none are known for problematic data practices.

Disclosure: Some links in this article are referral or affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely use and believe provide value. Full disclosure →